Tuesday, November 22, 2011

Shoddy Reporting on the Religion of Islam by ABC News, Part 2

I came across a critique of the ABC News 20/20 program, “Islam: Questions and Answers.” That program originally was broadcast a year ago. The recent YouTube exposé points out 20 errors in the hour long supposed ‘news’ program. This is a second of a series of posts that will delve into the various errors made by Diane Sawyer and her fellow staff on this program. I am not quite sure whether this was just bad or sloppy reporting, or merely a succumbing to political correctness, or outright lies about the so-called ‘religion’ of peace.
Here is the video, “Whitewashing Islam – 20 Errors on 20/20 (ABC News).” Following the video is a transcript of the next error found in the ‘news’ production.
.

Error #2
ABC’s Diane Sawyer says,
“In the beginning Adam and Eve, though in Islam God created them equally out of dust, not one from the other.”
David Wood responds, “Adam and Eve were created equally from dust according to the Qur’an. Diane does not give us a reference for the lovely teaching and she couldn’t if she tried, because the Qur’an does not say it. What does Qur’an say?

Surah 4:1 – O Mankind? Be dutiful to your Lord, who created you from a single person (Adam) and from him (Adam) He created his wife (Eve).
Surah 7:189 – It is he who hath created you from one person and out of him produced his wife that he might dwell with her.
“If that is not clear enough in …

Sahih al Bukhari 3331 – “Woman is created from a rib.”
“Are Men and women created equal from dust in Islam? Only if Diane Sawyer turns out to be a higher authority than Mohammed and the Qur’an!”

This error begs the question, “Where did Diane Sawyer get her (mis)information that in Islam men and women were created equal?” And, how deeply did she vet her sources? Who did the research for her, an Imam with a clear objective to deceive the American people?

The Judeo-Christian biblical account of creation clearly reveals that Eve was created out of Adam. Mohammad borrowed bits and pieces of the sacred scriptures when conjuring up his false ‘religion.’
The Qur’an itself is a mixture of some truth and fiction. In the case of creation, Diane Sawyer can’t even provide an accurate account of the Islamic version of creation. Maybe it is just her fanciful feminist version of creation. Regardless, inaccuracies abound in this 20/20 ‘news’ report on Islam.

Monday, November 21, 2011

Shoddy Reporting on the ‘Religion’ of Islam by ABC News, Part 1

I came across a critique of the ABC News 20/20 program, “Islam: Questions and Answers.” That program originally aired a year ago. The recent YouTube exposé by David Wood points out 20 errors in the hour long supposed ‘news’ program. This is a first of a series of posts that will delve into the various errors made by Diane Sawyer and her fellow reporters on this program. I am not quite sure whether this was just bad or sloppy reporting, or merely a succumbing to political correctness, or outright lies about the so-called ‘religion’ of peace.

Here is the video, “Whitewashing Islam – 20 Errors on 20/20 (ABC News).” Following the video is a transcript of the first few errors found in the production.
.
David Wood: “Islam is an honest reporter’s kryptonite. Take a seasoned journalist on a ground-breaking news program and ask him to give you the simplest, most basic, information about Mohammed and the Qur’an.  That reporter will suddenly turn into the most pathetic, trembling, sniveling, cowardly, journalistic jellyfish you will ever see in your entire life…
“Since all the Scooby Snacks in the world won’t convince anyone in the main stream media to flee the fortress of dhimmitude. The task now falls to viewers like us to demand some degree of journalistic integrity. We can do this by watching various news specials about Islam and exposing the endless supply of false claims and misrepresentations they assume we are too stupid to spot.
“If the networks start losing credibility over their dishonest reporting, if their inaccuracy has become a source of a bit embarrassment, maybe they will be a bit more careful the next time they decide to a puff piece on the religion of puff-peace! …
“There are plenty of news programs out there in dire need of a good public flogging and I intend to go through as many of them as possible in the coming months.  But where do we begin?
“Well to keep things simple, let’s go alphabetically.  A-B-C News masterfully demonstrated what we might call the frightened ostrich method of reporting in their 20/20 special, Islam, Questions and Answers. Our questions about Islam were answered by Diane Sawyer, Bill Weir, and Lama Hasan. The three blind mice of primetime political correctness.”
Error #1
ABC News Video: The following quotes are from three apparent Muslims in the ABC News program 20/20 on Islam:
(Believers of Islam) “Are just like everyone else.”
“Being a Muslim in America, in my opinion, doesn’t make me any different than anyone else.”
“110% American.”
David Wood: “If ABC had called this program, “What Westernized Muslims Believe,” I wouldn’t have a problem with Muslims saying, “We’re just like everyone else.” But this program is called, “Islam, Questions and Answers,” and not about Westernized Muslims! Muslims, who wouldn’t know the Qur’an from a phone book!
“What does Islam teach about Muslims?
Qur’an 3:110 – You are the best peoples ever raised up for mankind.
“Muslims are the best people in the world. How about Jews and Christians?
Surah 98:6 – Verily, those who disbelieve (in the religion of Islam, the Qur’an and Prophet Muhammad) from among the people of Scripture (Jews and Christians) and Al-Mushrikun (pagans) will abide in the fire of hell. They are the worst of creatures.
“We are the worst of creatures. Muslims are the best of peoples. According to the Qur’an are Muslims then, just like everyone else? Not a bit. ABC had a chance to explain this, but accurate information about Islam just isn’t a priority on their 20/20 special on Islam.”
So, obviously ABC News was biased in trying to present Islam and Muslims in the best light possible.  They tried to depict all adherents to Islam (1.5 Billion Muslims) as the very Westernized version (only 2 Million Muslims), which is not very representative at all. The Muslim’s guidebook teaches that Muslims are vastly superior other ‘creatures.’  So either the people recorded in the 20/20 program are woefully ignorant of their own religion’s teachings or they are lying or trying to deceive us.
To be continued ...

Sunday, November 20, 2011

The Radicals are in Control

A radical is someone who wants to bring about basic, fundamental change to a society’s values and social norms, and who works toward that end.  This is what Barack Husain Obama promised to do if he were elected president, to fundamentally change America. 

NO LONGER A CHRISTIAN NATION
One of his earliest changes was to proclaim that the United States of America was no longer a Christian nation, but is a Jewish nation, a Muslim nation, a Buddist nation, a Hindu nation, a nation of unbelievers ...

This meant that the United States, officially, no longer believed Jesus to be God in flesh, the only begotten Son of God. But, instead, Obama claims, like other adherers to or appeasers of Islam, that most in the U.S. now consider that Jesus is not God at all, but only one prophet among many.  The nation had, officially, gone from believing Jesus died on the cross for our sins to believing that Jesus was never crucified.  From believing Jesus is the only mediator between God and man to believing that man needs no mediator with God at all.  This shows that President Obama is not Christian, but believes something else.

ENSLAVING DEBT

During the President’s time in office he and the Democrats have increased the national debt by 40%.  Solomon, in the book of Proverbs, writes that the borrower is slave to the lender (Proverbs 22:7).  These actions are serving to enslave the nation and destroy what wealth its citizens have accumulated.   You can be sure that these people know exactly what they are doing.

REDISTRIBUTION OF WEALTH 

Profit is considered immoral.  Individuals and industries which have profit are considered evil and worthy of destruction.  Income is to be confiscated by tax and distributed to those who have earned less or nothing and granted to those who will help keep the Democrat politicians in power and in office.  This is Communism.

MAKING JESUS PERSONA NON GRATA

The Holy Bible, speaking of Jesus, and prayer (especially in the name of Jesus), is maligned, subverted even persecuted in education, government, industry, and by the courts.  This is communism at work in the United States.

ADVANCING MORAL RELATIVISM

These people have a moral structure in which godly morals are wrong and anything else is acceptable conduct.  God says woe to them that call evil good and good evil.  That are wise in their own eyes and prudent in their own sight (Isaiah 5:20, 21).  These people are communists.

THE ULTIMATE OUTCOME OF OBAMA’S RADICAL AGENDA

Scripture says, the wicked will be turned into hell and all the nations that forget God (Psalm 9:17). Can you see this happening in the United States of America?        

Saturday, November 19, 2011

Gingrich Earns Himself a Chicago-Style Political Beatin'

"Polls  now have Newt Gingrich near the top of the field for the GOP nomination.


 “You know what that means, the Chicago smear machine is NOW HIRING!”

--- NewsBusted, Episode 11/18/2011

NewsBusted is a conservative comedy webcast about the news of the day, uploaded every Tuesday and every Friday. Their newest NewBusted episode includes the excerpt above.

See right panel of this blog and click on the picture to watch this 2-3 minute comedy YouTube video.

Tuesday, November 15, 2011

Late Night Takes – On Debate Time and Bath Time

Late Night Jokes

Conan
Ron Paul’s campaign is upset because during last week's Republican presidential debate, he only got to speak for 89 seconds. Meanwhile, Rick Perry's campaign is upset because during last week's debate, he got to speak.

Over the weekend in New York, two Occupy Wall Street protesters got married at the protest. They are registered at Bed, Bath, and Seriously, You Need to Take a Bath.

Late Night With Jimmy Fallon

There was another Republican debate on Saturday, and listen to this: Ron Paul only got 89 seconds to speak. Seriously? Rick Perry gets more time than that to try to remember something.

These jokes are courtesy of NewsMax.com whichperiodically sends out an email compilation of jokes heard on late night TV talk shows, few of which are worth repeating . . . these were the exceptions.

Monday, November 14, 2011

Beware of the Chinese Food Invasion!


The Presidential couple, Barry Soetoro aka Barack and Michelle (head of the food gestapo) Obama, are on a Far East mission and/or vacation. He is discussing economic trade issues with leaders in that part of the world. Maybe he and his food-conscious wife should try exporting some of our burdensome environmental and agricultural regulations and taxation especially to the communist Chinese.

IT AIN’T AMERICAN APPLE PIE!

I normally don't use coupons very much when I go food shopping, but for some reason an ad in a Sunday newspaper caught my fancy. Finding a coupon for a Dole product, I was enticed to purchase it. I love apple crisp and Dole was a well-respected, dependable American brand, so one would think. However, I was shocked and dismayed when I saw the source of the apples used in the above pictured fruit crisp dessert.

It was sometime between the day I went shopping for the fruit crisp and the time I got around to eating the product, that I found that the apples were not American-sourced! Dole must really be an international conglomerate, which now imports its apples, not from the state of Washington, but from the communist Peoples Republic of China! I no longer had the same desire for the apple crisp as I did before I discovered were some of the ingredients came from! I thought about throwing out the product, suspecting that it may be laced with something undesirable. But, I took a chance and I did eventually eat the two small cups. I will not by this product again, however. I look warily on the Dole brand now.

Alas, my apple crisp is a world apple crisp. Imagine, just like we have world cars - cars assembled here in the USA made from parts imported from Mexico, Canada, South Korea and/or Japan, we now have world apple crisp. Apple crisp, which is merely assembled here in the USA from components from around the world, including unsanitary under-regulated lead-in-the-paint-toys and slave-labor-produced-Christmas-Tree-Lights and who knows what other shoddy inferior, unsafe junk we import from our new would-be masters?

NO FISH STORY

Speaking about the real Red state, the newsletter, America's Future, Vol. 52, No. 11/12, November-December 2010), reported in an article, "Update on China's Unsanitary Aquaculture," a summary of a long and in-depth Bloomberg Businessweek piece:

80% of the tilapia (fish) eaten in the U.S. is grown on fish farms in China, and (it is) frozen before it is imported into our country.  According to the U.S. Agriculture Dept. Economic Research Services, Chinese fish “are often raised in ponds where they feed on waste from poultry and livestock.” When the tilapia are young, farmers toss animal waste in the ponds to feed the tilapia. Various experts in the industry say the Chinese cut their feed costs because they use manure for food. Chinese tilapia are therefore much cheaper. Costco won’t buy Chinese tilapia because of production practices. A Costco buyer says Chinese processors use a glaze on frozen fillet that “contains carbon monoxide, which preserves the color of the fish and can make a fillet look fresher than it is … Even if the fish starts to go bad, the fish will look good.” Unlike salmon, tuna and other big ocean fish, tilapia doesn’t contain omega-3 oils, one of the main health benefits of seafood.

I used to like tilapia. I bought it a few times at Denny’s Restaurant. I never realized that that there was such a huge chance that that fish came from the crap-feed fish farms of America’s Far East nemesis and major credit holder. I have been buying tilapia from Kroger’s. After reading the article I asked where the fish came from and the package says from farms in Honduras or Costa Rica. I now wonder if they came by way of  Red China? In either case from now on I won’t take a chance and I’ll stick with salmon and avoid all tilapia!

THE LESSON TO BE LEARNED

Americans must begin to read the labels on all food products we purchase. We must never assume that even brand name can be trusted any longer. They cannot be. Before you order tilapia in the restaurant, ask where it came from and if they don’t know, don’t buy it because there is a high probability it came from highly underregulated polluted Chinese ponds.  

Sunday, November 13, 2011

Alien Invasion of the World

In fiction, books and movies, there have been many battles between the inhabitants of the earth and invaders from outer space.  To my knowledge, the peoples of the earth have always won these wars.  Such titles come to mind as, “Independence Day”, and “War of the Worlds”.  The Holy Bible speaks of a war, also, in which the earth is invaded by a conquering army from beyond space, heaven.

Back in the days when several European nations were colonizing real estate around the world, a representative from that nation would travel to the new land and claim it for the emperor of the nation from which he came.  In Scripture, we find an angel from heaven doing the same thing on earth.

Revelation 10:1-3 - And I saw another mighty angel come down from heaven, clothed with a cloud: and a rainbow was upon his head, and his face was as it were the sun, and his feet as pillars of fire:  And he had in his hand a little book open: and he set his right foot upon the sea, and his left foot on the earth,  And cried with a loud voice, as when a lion roareth: and when he had cried, seven thunders uttered their voices.

Revelation 10:5-7 - And the angel which I saw stand upon the sea and upon the earth lifted up his hand to heaven, And sware by him that liveth for ever and ever, who created heaven, and the things that therein are, and the earth, and the things that therein are, and the sea, and the things which are therein, that there should be time no longer:  But in the days of the voice of the seventh angel, when he shall begin to sound, the mystery of God should be finished, as he hath declared to his servants the prophets.
This is the advance claim on behalf of the King of Heaven on earth, that the earth and all that is there in belongs to the King of Heaven.

Is the King of Heaven, your King?   

Saturday, November 12, 2011

Just What Did the Obama 'Stimulus' Stimulate?



“There are now over one-hundred (100) criminal probes investigating the money doled out under the 2009 ‘stimulus.’

“Or, as the ‘stimulus’ is also called, the List of Obama’s Campaign Donors!”


Episode 11/11/2011


NewsBusted is a conservative comedy webcast about the news of the day, uploaded every Tuesday and every Friday. Their two lastest episodes includs the excerpts above.

See right panel of this blog and click on the picture to watch this 2-3 minute comedy YouTube video.

Thursday, November 10, 2011

Bob Schulz Engages "Occupy"


I don't agree with everything that Schulz says, but I think that he is on to something here.  Instead of complaining and vilifying the Occupy Wall Street movement, why not use this as an opportunity to educate them?


October 29, 2011
SCHULZ GOES TO WALL STREET
Gives The Constitution A Voice

At 9 AM on Saturday, October 8, I was tuned into CNN, broadcasting from Atlanta. The Host was interviewing three young people who had participated in "Occupy Atlanta" the day before. One was a 26 year old female veteran back from the hostilities in Iraq and Afghanistan and enrolled in College. The other two were males in their 20's who were employed. 
The host asked what the Occupy movement was all about. The young people said, "We want to fix the system."  
The host asked how the system could be fixed. The young people struggled to find an answer but had none. Eventually they suggested more people should vote.  
I turned to Judy, my wife, saying, "That's it. I'm going down there. These folks need to know about the Constitution and how it can solve their grievances."  Four hours later, we were in New York City.  I had a thought to find a meeting room somewhere near to the protests so I could talk about Liberty and the Constitution to whomever might come. Research uncovered a new community center two blocks away called Charlotte's Place."  We were able to make contact with and then meet with the director in between visits to the Park who agreed to give us time to meet there with interested people.  
As we walked among the protestors, we observed many who were clean-cut, bright eyed as they moved throughout the crowd open to exchanging ideas with strangers.  
I noticed a table with a homemade sign, "INFO." I approached and asked, "How can I conduct a teach-in on the State and Federal Constitutions? The young man said, "Start a Working Group." I asked, "How do I do that."  He said, "Announce it." I asked, "How." He said, "Get up on a bench and yell, 'Mic Check.'" That will get the attention of the People."  
I did just that. The People turned their attention to me and began to repeat, in waves, every few words I said.  I announced I was starting a Constitution Working Group, that the Constitution can be used to control the Bankers, the Corporations and the Politicians, end undeclared wars, end Bailouts, end the Fed and end our debt-based, fiat currency.   Each part of the message was repeated two or three times as the crowds carried the words and energy back to others farther away.  I announced the first meeting of the State and Federal Constitution Working Group would be at 6 PM on the steps at the east end of the Plaza. 
Cheers were heard and People raised both hands, pointing all their (wiggling) fingers upwards. I learned later that was a hand signal expressing approval.  
Before I could descend from the bench, 20-25 people surrounded me, some asking questions. What became clear to me was they knew little to nothing about the content, history, meaning, effect and significance of any provision of their State and Federal Constitutions. I lectured from the park bench for more than 30 minutes, before someone else from a distance yelled, "Mic Check," drawing attention to the new speaker. 
Before my 6 PM meeting I learned OWS had a General Assembly (GA) meeting every evening about 7 PM, run by a group of "facilitators." 
At the 6 PM meeting people signed up to be on the Constitution Working Group, providing their names and email addresses.  
Before the start of the GA, I engaged in a loud conversation with a student from the Rochester Institute of Technology (RIT) in New York about his grievances and the Constitution. He started out expressing his anger at the greed and corruption on Wall Street, Again, dozens of young People, apparently genuinely eager to learn, gathered around to listen to the conversation.  
After more mingling, I did another "Mic Check," announcing there would be a meeting of the State and Federal Constitution Working Group on Wednesday at Charlotte's Place and those who would like to be on the Working Group should meet me on the Steps. More people signed up, bringing the total to 29, including two attorneys (one of whom is a professor of Financial Law at Cornell and under contract to teach Financial Regulations to folks at the New York Federal Reserve (ponder this for a moment), a young veteran combat photographer, another young veteran, a high school math teacher, a full time student at PACE U., and so on.  Again I was impressed at the level of intelligence and sincerity of the people who were there. 
On Wednesday, eight of the 29 met (we have since learned it is difficult to schedule meetings when all can meet, given the diversity of everyone's professions and occupations). 
A consensus was reached regarding a simple, one or two word definition of the overriding grievances of OWS: Money, Debt, Bailouts, Federal Reserve, Corporate Personhood and the (Undeclared) Wars. 
There was a discussion of the five Rights guaranteed by the First Amendment, with emphasis on the meaning of the fifth: the Right to Petition for Redress. Packets of study materials were distributed including copies of the State and Federal Constitutions, the Articles of Freedom, WTP's "Interpretation of the Meaning of the Right to Petition Government for Redress of Grievances," the lawsuit filed by me in 2008 against the AIG bailout, the lawsuit filed by me in 2008 against the $700 billion bailout of the financial industry, We the People of New York, Inc.'s Certificate of Incorporation and the pamphlet written by Benedict D. LaRosa, "Democracy or Republic, Which Is It?" 
Since then, we have had two more meetings in NYC and one Webinar. Judith Whitmore has joined me in this effort. Thus far, an agreement has been reached on the Beliefs of the State and Federal Constitution Working Group as follows: 
  •  All People have Natural Rights -- Simply Because They Are Alive.
  •  We the People have Instituted Government to Secure our Rights.
  •  According to our Governing Documents, Sovereignty rests with the People.
  •  The Constitution & Declaration of Independence are inextricably intertwined.
  •  Every Principle, Prohibition, Restriction and Mandate of our Governing Documents represents a Guaranteed, Individual Right.
  •  The People are the Source of All Political Power
    (after all no one gets into office unless we put them there).
  •  All Elected Officials are limited by our written Constitutions
    (if not authorized in writing, such acts are unlawful).
  •  The Constitution is not a Menu.
  •  The Constitution cannot Defend Itself.
  • Individuals and Small Groups cannot prevail in attempts to hold government accountable to their State and Federal Constitutions.
  •  A Critical Mass is needed, say 3-5% of population.
  •  Very few in and out of public office can recognize when government is obeying or violating the Constitution.
  •  The way our system of governance is working is in sharp contrast to the way it is designed to work.
  •  We don't change the Constitution by ignoring it; There are provisions within it to make changes. 
  •  All that is happening is our fault; the People have allowed it to happen.
  • The People have always had the ultimate power in our society and have always been the final arbiters of constitutionality.
  •  Most of what is causing our National distress NOW can be traced back to violations of the Constitution. 
The next step, before next Monday's Webinar is to prepare drafts of Petitions for Redress which will include Instructions to the President and Congress to Remedy the agreed upon Grievances, each involving a violation of the Constitution: Money, Debt, Bailouts, Federal Reserve, Corporate Personhood and Undeclared Wars.  
Once a consensus is reached on an Instruction, it will be forwarded to the OWS facilitators and announced at Liberty Plaza following a "Mic Check."  If there are enough people who support the Petitions/Instructions, this is a peaceful legal way that the "99%" and the Constitution can be heard. 
From those I have talked to or heard from, there has been real relief expressed that someone is pointing the way back to the Constitution. However, there are different viewpoints on who is back of OWS; what its real purpose is; what is going to take place because of it.  
IMHO, the OWS may morph into a more formal, national organization something like our Constitution Lobby, albeit possibly without incorporating. The danger is it may be co-opted by a person(s) with an agenda contrary to that of the Constitution Lobby. With that in mind it will be interesting to see how much respect the Constitution Working Group actually receives from the powers behind OWS, whoever they are. 
I will continue until the Constitution is back as the main-frame for America and our Nation is back on track.

Bob Schulz,
Founder, We The People

Sunday, November 06, 2011

God Will Rule on Earth

Now to the King eternal, immortal, invisible, the only wise God, be honor and glory for ever and ever. Amen. 1 Timothy 1:17 KJV
.
Daniel interpreted a dream for King Nebuchadnezzar. In the dream a rock ground the statue of a man to powder and encompassed the whole earth.  The rock represented the great God setting up a kingdom, which destroyed all the kingdoms of earth and ruled over all the earth.  The nations we see in existence today will not exist forever.  One day God will rule on earth.
Daniel 2:44: And in the days of these kings shall the God of heaven set up a kingdom, which shall never be destroyed: and the kingdom shall not be left to other people, but it shall break in pieces and consume all these kingdoms, and it shall stand for ever.
Daniel 4:34: And at the end of the days I Nebuchadnezzar lifted up my eyes unto heaven, and mine understanding returned to me, and I blessed the most High, and I praised and honored him that liveth for ever, whose dominion is an everlasting dominion, and his kingdom is from generation to generation.
Daniel 6:26: I make a decree, That in every dominion of my kingdom men tremble and fear before the God of Daniel: for he is the living God, and steadfast for ever, and his kingdom that which shall not be destroyed, and his dominion shall be even unto the end.
.
Are you in that kingdom?  If you are born again, then you are in the kingdom of God.  If you are not born again,  you are not in the kingdom of God and need to become born again.  One enters the kingdom of God by believing Jesus died for them, repenting of their sin, and inviting Jesus into ones heart.
.
A sample payer is, “Lord Jesus Christ, forgive me of my sin and come into my heart.”
.
At the present time, the kingdom of God is within each and every believer.            

Saturday, November 05, 2011

Unremarkable Anniversary

He'll Occupy White House One More Year

Hat tip goes to OFA (Organizing for America, President Barack Obama’s on-going campaign organization) for the following terrible reminder:
“Three years ago today, Barack Obama was elected President of the United States.”

Therefore, I consider this day to be a very tragic date in American History. The Obama regime is an American catastrophe of immense proportions. This day is also a reminder that elections have significant and long-lasting consequences!

We must right the wrong of the 2008 Election in the Primary Election season of 2012. We must select a true conservative (i.e. not Mitt “Flip Flop,” “Finger in the Political Wind” Romney, or any other fake, establishment sanctioned John McCain ‘conservative’ candidate). We must a follow-through and elect that conservative President, as well as a conservative Congress in the 2012 election itself!
Until Barack Obama leaves office, he remains an Obstacle for America OFA! He must, himself, become a unemployment statistic as soon as possible. America will be better off only when Obama begins to collect his much undeserved and unearned government retirement check!

O must gO in 2O12!

Thursday, November 03, 2011

Vote No on Ohio Issue 1, 2011

Hear Barry Sheets and Chuck Michaelis on their new radio show "Principles and Policies" talk about Issue 1 at the links below:

part 1: http://www.principledpolicy.com/?p=982
part 2: http://www.principledpolicy.com/?p=984

I don't think that there should be any age limits for judges at all.  But while I disagree with Barry and Chuck about raising the age limits, I am glad that they called to my attention that this is not the only issue addressed by Issue 1.  Issue 1 would repeal an 1851 provision which allowed the General Assembly to create courts of conciliation and an 1867 provision allowing a Supreme Court Commission to be created to deal with backlogs.  Courts of conciliation were designed in part to help stop divorces.  Please read the article at the following URL before voting on this issue:

http://www.divorcereform.info/index.php/Failure-of-Current-Divorce-Laws/Marriage-Saving-in-Court-Ohio-s-Conciliation-of-Marital-Controversies.html

Here is the ballot language:

1  PROPOSED CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT 
TO INCREASE THE MAXIMUM AGE AT WHICH A PERSON MAY BE ELECTED OR APPOINTED JUDGE, TO ELIMINATE THE AUTHORITY OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY TO ESTABLISH COURTS OF CONCILIATION, AND TO ELIMINATE THE AUTHORITY OF THE GOVERNOR TO APPOINT A SUPREME COURT COMMISSION PROPOSED BY JOINT RESOLUTION OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY TO AMEND SECTION 6 OF ARTICLE IV AND TO REPEAL SECTIONS 19 AND 22 OF ARTICLE IV OF THE CONSTITUTION OF THE STATE OF OHIO 


A majority yes vote is required for the amendment to Section 6 and the repeal of Sections 19 and 22 to pass. 
This proposed amendment would: 
1.  Increase the maximum age for assuming elected or appointed judicial office from seventy to seventy-five. 
2.  Eliminate the General Assembly’s authority to establish courts of conciliation. 
3.  Eliminate the Governor’s authority to appoint members to a Supreme Court Commission. 
If approved, the amendment shall take effect immediately. 
A “YES” vote means approval of the amendment to Section 6 and the repeal of Sections 19 and 22. 
A “NO” vote means disapproval of the amendment to Section 6 and the repeal of Sections 19 and 22. 

Vote Y3S! On Issue 3


OK, its time to get out and vote for issue 3!  If you vote "no" you are saying that you want to be a slave.  Many people have argued with me about this.  They say that it will cost more money to take care of the poor slobs who need healthcare, but don't have insurance.  But how much is it going to cost to jail the people who refuse to buy the insurance and refuse to pay the resulting fine?  And if this is not enforced, then there is no point in it.  If you don't buy health insurance, is that really a crime?  On scale from one to ten, one being petty theft and ten being cold-blooded, premeditated, mass murder, where does not buying health insurance fall?   And how much insurance is enough?  If you think that the government must make that decision for you, then you have made yourself a slave.

What to do about Issue 2?



There have been many deceptive statements made about Issue 2 on both sides.  For example, the “vote no” side has said that firefighters would not be able to get the equipment that they need if it passed.  But this is what the final analysis of Legislative Service Commission says:

“Although the act limits the topics of collective bargaining as described above, under the act, equipment issues directly related to personal safety are subject to collective bargaining.”

Many people on both sides keep repeating misstatements like this about Issue 2 because they have not read it.  Now, I can see voting “no” on something if you have read only part of it and you have found something in it that you are absolutely opposed to.  Once you get to that point, there is no point in reading it any further.  But no one should vote yes on something unless you have read it (and understood it).  Otherwise, you have no right to complain about Congressman and Senators voting for bills that they don’t read.  It’s the same thing.  But it doesn’t necessarily mean that you have to vote “no” on it.  It is perfectly honorable to abstain from voting on something you don’t understand or don’t know.

Now before you read the actual bill, it would be better to read the final analysis of Legislative Service Commission (LSC).  These are the folks who actually wrote the bill.  (Legislators don’t actually write the bills.  They get an idea for a bill and send it to the LSC.  The LSC then translates it into legalese, finds the appropriate place(s) in the Ohio Revised Code for it to be added, eliminates or changes any laws that may conflict with the legislator’s idea, and writes a legal summary so that folks can find out what the bill does without having to read hundreds of pages.)  Now even this LSC summary (called the final analysis) is fifty pages long.  But is it too much to ask for you even to read this much before voting yes on it?  I have read both the LSC final analysis AND the actual bill.

What Does S.B. 5 Say About Strikes?

“The act also prohibits any public employee or any employee organization from causing, instigating, encouraging, or condoning a strike.”

So while I agree that public employees should not be allowed to strike, S.B. 5 goes way too far.  This is Orwellian territory.  I would put making it a crime to encourage or condone something into the same category as hate and thought crime legislation, something that I have spoken out against many times on this blog.  It would clearly be a violation of the freedom of speech to make such a thing a crime.

For this striking (or condoning of it) the employee loses not only pay for the day(s) in which the employee was on strike, but an additional day’s pay is also taken from the employee.  This is clearly a fine.  (This would not be the case if the employee was merely docked pay for the days that he was on strike, or if he was fired, demoted, suspended or had his salary reduced for it.  Taking back money that was already given to him in the manner that is prescribed by S.B. 5 is unconstitutional property deprivation as you will see by reading on.)  The employee does not have to be charged with a crime in order for this penalty to be levied and the principle of innocent until proven guilty is not regarded in the procedure for penalizing the employee.   The penalties are assessed BEFORE the accused employee is given any hearing at all.  The LSC final analysis makes the following three disturbing statements:

“If…the hearing officer determines…that the employee did not violate any of the prohibitions the chief fiscal officer must [stop]…all further deductions and refund any deductions previously made pursuant to the act.”

“The employee bears the burden of proof at the hearing.”

“The act prohibits…any court of competent jurisdiction from waiving the penalties or fines assessed regarding a violation of any of those prohibitions as part of the settlement of an illegal strike.”

Thus the hearing that the employee is entitled to is not a trial by jury, violating Article I, section 5, Ohio Constitution which says,

“The right of trial by jury shall be inviolate, except that, in civil cases, laws may be passed to authorize the rendering of a verdict by the concurrence of not less than three-fourths of the jury.”

(If there is anyone out there who reads my articles, you know that I do not believe that the 14th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution was properly ratified.  But if you believe that it was properly ratified, then for you, its Due Process clause would also be another way to prove that S.B. 5 is unconstitutional.)

But yet, the public employer is afforded all of these rights.  The LSC final analysis says,

“Whenever a strike occurs, the public employer may seek an injunction against the strike in the court of common pleas of the county in which the strike is located.  Under continuing law, an unfair labor practice by a public employer is not a defense to the injunction proceeding.”

The Obligation of Contracts

The LSC final analysis says,

“Any bargaining unit of a fire department that does not conform to this requirement on the act’s effective date ceases to be an appropriate unit upon the expiration of the collective bargaining agreement covering that unit that is in effect on the act’s effective date or three years after the act’s effective date, whichever is earlier.”

Whether you agree with collective bargaining agreements or not, a deal is a deal.  The above provision could void existing contracts.  This could potentially create a violation of Article I, section 10 of the U.S. Constitution which says,

“No state shall…pass any…Law impairing the Obligation of Contracts…”

This is also a principle upon which our entire system of government is based, since the law itself is a contract between the People and the government.

Privatization

As I have stated before, I am all for privatization in most instances.  But when it comes to law enforcement, I say no way.  Here is what the LSC summary says about privatization:

“The act further prohibits any agreement entered into or renewed under the PECBL on or after the act’s effective date from containing any provision that in any way prohibits a public employer from entering into a contract with another public or private sector entity to privatize the public employer’s services or the contracting out of the public employer’s work.”

There is no exception given for police officers, prison guards, or other officers of the law.  If they would have put in such an exception, then I would be OK with it.  But this is dangerous.

How Will Teacher Pay be Determined Under S.B. 5?

The LSC final analysis says,

“The evaluation on which a teacher’s pay must be based is a new evaluation under the act…At least 50% of each evaluation must be based on measures of student academic growth specified by the [State] Department of Education…. The State Board must review the [Superintendent’s] recommendations [and] must vote either to adopt the recommended frameworks for evaluations or to request that the Superintendent reconsider the recommendations… [and if the Board disapproves] the Board must modify the frameworks prior to adopting them.” 

So it will not be the parents of the children who will decide the criteria for how public school teachers will be compensated, not even indirectly through their locally elected school board members.  It will be bureaucrats in Columbus who will have all of the influence on these decisions.

S.B. 5 mandates that teachers and other public employees be graded by the use of these performance evaluations.  This may seem like a good idea, and I am not opposed to it in general, but I know how these things usually end up because I am an exempt unrepresented state employee myself (but not a teacher).  (Being unrepresented, I am not subject to any collective bargaining agreement and therefore my pay is adjusted, at least in part, based on such evaluations.)  But whenever my boss wants to give me a raise (and if there is no pay freeze in effect) he fills out the forms and makes sure that the measures of rating my performance improve over the last time I was evaluated.  I am not saying that my boss did anything wrong, I do believe that he honestly wants to give me raises that I deserve, but filling out the forms is just going through the motions.  If he wanted to give me raises despite poor performance, no one would ever know the difference.  So this whole evaluations thing, though much better than a longevity-based system, is really no big deal.  It’s all subjective and unenforceable.

More Bureaucracy

I don’t see one place in S.B. 5 where any bureaucracy is eliminated.  We still have all the same overlords plus one more.  The LSC final analysis says,

“The act creates the Ohio Commission for Excellence in Public Service, which consists of at least 7 and not more than 11 voting members.”

This is just another board to which politicians can appoint those who have helped campaign for them or their party.  There is even also a touch of globalism in this new commission:

“The Commission is required to consult with public and private organizations located internationally…”

Conclusion

S.B. 5 may save a lot of money (in the short run) and prevent some unfair practices, but you have to look at the bigger picture.  All of these gains are not worth it if you have to violate the Constitution in order to get them.  If this issue passes and the unconstitutional provisions of S.B. 5 are upheld as legal by the courts, the resulting precedents could be used against us.  S.B. 5 does not really address the most relevant problem anyway, which is the centralization of power. (In many instances it actually increases the centralization of power.)  If we would just allow local communities to make their own decisions regarding compensation for local public employees, and make the funding of these positions local instead of pouring state money into them, then I believe the legitimate reasons for supporting S.B. 5 would be dealt with more effectively.  I will vote “no” on Issue 2.