Showing posts with label Constitutional Amendment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Constitutional Amendment. Show all posts

Thursday, October 15, 2015

Vote No on Ohio Issue 1, 2015

Issue 1 is a proposed amendment to the Ohio Constitution which would change the apportionment process and rules for redistricting Ohio house and senate districts.

Issue 1 does nothing at all about the apportionment of congressional district seats.  This is where the vast majority of the gerrymandering occurs. 

Issue 1 takes the job of drawing the district lines out of the hands of the legislature and gives it to a new board called the “Ohio Redistricting Commission”.  I oppose this because, if at all possible, all of the laws of our state should be made by the legislature.  That is the definition of a republic, which is required by the U.S. Constitution.  Having said that, I realize that redistricting legislation is a special case that deserves special consideration.  It is legislation that must be enacted in order to preserve the state.  But the commission issue 1 describes should only be used as a last resort (that is, if the legislature fails to pass a redistricting bill).  But issue 1 would do the opposite, making the legislature’s choice the last resort.  If the amendment contained enough precise rules to virtually determine the drawing of the lines, then there would be no need to involve the legislature and a redistricting board would only be charged with finding the correct map.  For example, a provision could have been added to the amendment that would say that of all possible maps which satisfy the other redistricting rules, the one that has the least variation in district population is the one that must be used.  But this amendment has nothing like that.    

The “Ohio Redistricting Commission” would consist of the same members as the current Apportionment Board plus two members appointed by the minority party leaders in the House and Senate respectively.  I oppose the addition of these members because it grants a privilege that is based on party affiliation.  George Washington said in his farewell address that political parties are bad for America.  We should not do anything to encourage them.  The addition of these two extra members favors Republicans and Democrats and discriminates against third parties and independents.
 
The amendment contains language that says that a redistricting plan must not favor any particular political party.  Do you really think that the “Ohio Redistricting Commission” is going follow such a subjective provision as that even with two minority party members out of seven?  I oppose any law respecting political party for the reasons mentioned in the previous paragraph.   The only way to prevent the lines from being drawn in a way that favors certain groups of people is to add more objective rules so that there is only one possible choice for how the lines can be drawn.  It is not necessary for any of these rules to take into account the party affiliation of voters.

The amendment contains language that says the districts must be compact.  It does not say how compact the districts must be in order for it to be an acceptable map.  I am in favor of compact districts, but the word “compact” is not defined in amendment and is therefore just as subjective as the concept of favoritism based on political party.  The amendment is not clear about which of these two objectives should have precedence in a case where both cannot be achieved.

The amendment cow-tows to the judiciary.  It contains language that basically says that if the court
(of competent jurisdiction) rules that it doesn’t like anything about this amendment, then we must disregard the parts that they don’t like even if they aren’t really unconstitutional.  The whole process would be subject to this scrutiny, not just what’s being changed by the amendment.  Remember, Jefferson said that the courts are not the final arbiters of the constitution.

The amendment contains basically the same constraints on the how the lines must be drawn in regards to existing boundaries of counties, cities and townships.  Issue 1 has some language that more precisely defines these rules and their order of precedence.  This is the only advantage I see in issue 1, but in my mind, it is far outweighed by all its disadvantages. 


Redistricting reform is needed, but issue 1 does not do what is really needed.

Thursday, October 08, 2015

Vote No on Ohio Issue 2, 2015


Issue 2 has two purposes.  One is to prevent Issue 3 (the marijuana amendment) from coming into effect even if it passes.  The second purpose is to prevent the establishment of future monopolies through the amendment process.

I agree with the purposes of the issue, but not the way in which its framers are trying to achieve them.  The language of issue 2 claims that if it passes, issue 3 will not go into effect even it does pass.  But the Ohio Constitution says the following in Article II section 1b :
If conflicting proposed laws or conflicting proposed amendments to the constitution shall be approved at the same election by a majority of the total number of votes cast for and against the same, the one receiving the highest number of affirmative votes shall be the law, or in the case of amendments to the constitution shall be the amendment to the constitution.
So therefore the only scenario in which issue 2 would achieve its first purpose would be if issue 2 passed with a higher number votes than issue 3.  This seems highly unlikely to me.  I would estimate that 95% of the people who vote “yes” on issue 3 will vote “no” on issue 2.  A significant number of voters always vote “no” everything and this number is likely to be larger in this election.

The language included to attempt to prevent future monopolies is weak.  The Ballot Board, consisting of the Secretary of State and four others chosen by Ohio law (Article XVI, section 1), would have the power to determine if an issue to amend the constitution establishes a monopoly.  If they find that it does, then another issue would be put on the ballot stating that the opposing issue establishes a monopoly and that if this issue passes, then the other would not go into effect.  In other words, you would have to pass two issues instead of one to establish what Ballot Board considers a monopoly.  This is unlikely to do any good for the same reason that the first purpose is unlikely to be accomplished.  It essentially assumes that the voters are too stupid to decide these things for themselves.

And of course issue 2 does nothing to repeal existing monopolies that have already been placed into the constitution.  A prime example is the gambling amendment that passed a few years ago.  

So what’s the harm in passing issue 2?  Ohio already allows us to put issues on the ballot without the approval of the legislature.  This really already puts Ohio outside the definition of a republic which is a violation of the Article IV section 4 of the U.S. Constitution.  But giving the Ballot Board the authority to put issues on the ballot extends this unconstitutionality even further.  We are supposed to be a republic, not a democracy.  This means that all of our state laws must be passed by our legislature.  And any law that establishes a monopoly is essentially a Bill of Attainder which is unconstitutional under the federal constitution.  The Ohio Supreme Court already has the authority deny the enforcement of such laws.  The vague phrase "similarly situated persons or nonpublic entities" is dangerous, giving the Ballot Board and/or the courts a lot wiggle room for interpretation.  Its hard enough to get the courts apply the laws correctly when they are simple and well-written.


Thursday, March 29, 2012

Who In the World Said That?!



 Patrick Johnston, the director of Personhood Ohio, has come up with an interesting contest.  Personhood Ohio exists to support the Ohio Personhood Amendment, the only proposed legislation to restore all God given rights to the unborn in Ohio.  Here is Patrick's idea:
A couple weeks ago, the Johnston family manned a booth at the Cleveland Right to Life Convention. Hundreds signed and took petitions and lit, and we had lengthy conversations with many faithful pro-lifers - including several positive conversations with leaders reluctant to support our Personhood Amendment. Tom Raddell, George Porter and I met with two theological consultants to the Ohio Catholic bishops, and had a very profitable discussion. 
Pray that the seeds sown will bear fruit, and that these leaders will catch the vision to end abortion in Ohio this year through the Ohio Personhood Amendment. For a prize, see if you can match up the quote with the pro-life leader:  
1. "I agree with the Ohio Personhood Amendment in principle - personhood should be established at conception - but I don't think it will work."

2. "I know Section B of your Amendment says that 'This Amendment shall not affect genuine contraception' that doesn't kill children, but some can interpret that to mean that this Amendment shall affect contraception. Just mentioning contraception can be seen as an endorsement of contraception."  
3. "I'm against personhood. It's bad strategy. Roe versus Wade is the law of the land."  
4. "Put personhood amendments aside [and] focus on ending abortion."  
5. "We're working with Tom Raddell, and gathering signatures in front of the abortion clinic and at my parish."
6. "The Supreme Court wouldn't uphold the Ohio Personhood Amendment if it passed. We need a Human Life Amendment at the federal level to end abortion here."  
7. After signing and then crossing out his own signature, he said, "If the Ohio Personhood Amendment passed, then the liberals will be taking busloads of pregnant women to other states to get their abortions."  
A. Denise Mackura, former director of Ohio RTL 
B. Mike Gonadakis, director of Ohio RTL 
C. Austin Ruse, president of Catholic Family and Human Rights Institute 
D. Steve Ertelt, editor of Life News 
E. Amy Mushinski, Cleveland director, 40 Days for Life 
F. Theological consultant to the Ohio bishops 
G. David Yost, State Auditor 
The one who gets it right (or gets closest) gets a signed copy of my novel - The Revolt of 2020 - for FREE (plus $29.95 for shipping and handling). Post your answer on our Personhood Ohio facebook page. 
(Just kidding about the shipping and handling fee :-)
I think that this idea would be more fun if the quotations were from more well known politicians.  Maybe we should come up with a contest like this for the Presidential candidates!

Thursday, March 01, 2012

Stop Term Limit Violators


This is in response to Greg’s posts “Time for Tiberi Term Limit” and “Why Term Limit Congress!”. 

I personally oppose term limits because they disqualify candidates who may be perfectly able to serve their country.  There is no magic bullet for stopping tyranny.  There is no substitute for education, vigilance, and a virtuous, Christian majority.

However, Ohio’s voters went to the polls in 1992 and legally voted for a state constitutional amendment to impose term limits on its U.S. Representatives and Senators.  The Supreme Court, without constitutional basis, struck down this amendment.  But the law is still on the books for all to see:

“No person shall hold the office of United States Senator from Ohio for a period longer than two successive terms of six years. No person shall hold the office of United States Representative from Ohio for a period longer than four successive terms of two years. Terms shall be considered successive unless separated by a period of four or more years. Only terms beginning on or after January 1, 1993 shall be considered in determining an individual’s eligibility to hold office.”

Article V, Section 8, Constitution of Ohio

So, though I don’t personally agree with term limits, term limits for Ohio’s Representatives are just valid as any other law.  The Supreme Court’s decision was nothing less than pure tyranny.  Therefore, any honorable congressman will abide by these limits despite the opinion of the black-robed bandits.  And it is the duty of Ohio voters to refrain from voting for the term limit violators.  Otherwise, you are abetting a criminal.  Those who have violated the law (or will violate it if elected this year) are: 

Steve Chabot, Jean Schmidt, Mike Turner, John Boehner, Dennis Kucinich, Pat Tibieri, Marcy Kaptur, Steve LaTourette, and Tim Ryan.

None of these candidates are a “Good Choice” in this election!

22 other states besides Ohio also passed term limits on their representatives in Congress.  These are Alaska, Arizona, Arkansas, California, Colorado, Florida, Idaho, Maine, Massachusetts, Michigan, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, Nevada, New Hampshire, North Dakota, Oklahoma, Oregon, South Dakota, Utah, Washington, and Wyoming. If you live in one of these states, check your state constitution or state code to find out what the laws are, and don’t vote for any who are in violation of it!

Thursday, November 18, 2010

The Right Way to Amend the Constitution, part 21

This is part twenty-one of an ongoing series of articles containing my proposals for amendments to the Constitution.  For someone who claims so fervently to be a “Constitutionalist”, how is it that I can be so eager to change the Constitution?  Well, there are several reasons.  For one thing, I believe that after the Bill of Rights, much damage was done by some of the amendments that were added and the legitimacy of some of their ratifications are questionable.  Secondly, the Constitution has been violated so much that the necessity of further amendments is needed to resolve the resulting problems.  But this should be done extremely cautiously.  My amendments are extremely unlikely to ever be introduced, much less ratified, but hey, I can dream, can’t I?

Here is another of my amendments (subject to revision):

Section 1.  The seventeenth article of amendment to the Constitution of the United States is hereby repealed.

Section 2.  The Legislatures of each State shall assemble in years preceding the year in which the term of a Senator is to begin, on the first Monday in August unless it shall by law appoint a different day.  On this day, the members of each Branch of the State Legislature shall vote by ballot for one person for Senator.  The Senator shall then be elected by the people of the State from among all those receiving the most votes in at least one Branch of the Legislature of the State.  The electors for this purpose shall have the qualifications requisite for electors of the most numerous Branch of the State Legislature in each respective State.

Section 3.  In even numbered years, in States which would not ordinarily elect a Senator in that year, a Vice Senator shall be elected to a term of six years beginning on the 3d day of January of the following year.  The election shall be carried out at the same times, in the same manner, and with the qualifications for electors as election of a Senator.  No person constitutionally ineligible to the office of Senator shall be eligible to that of Vice Senator.

Section 4.  Whenever there is a vacancy in the office of Senator, the Vice Senator of the same State shall assume the vacant office.  When there is a vacancy in the office of Vice Senator, the executive authority of the State shall make a temporary appointment until the next meeting of the Legislature of the affected State, which shall then fill the vacancy, unless they shall have provided by law other means by which the office would be filled as soon as it became vacant. 

Section 5.  If, at the time fixed for the beginning of the term of a Senator, the Senator elect shall have died or if no candidate for the office shall have qualified, then the Vice Senator shall become Senator.  If a Senator dies, resigns, or is removed from office and the office of Vice Senator is vacant, then the office of Senator shall be filled in the manner in which it would have been if this amendment had not been adopted unless the Legislature of the affected State shall have otherwise directed by law.

Section 6.  Sections 4 and 5 shall not take effect until every State shall have chosen a Vice Senator.  This amendment shall not be construed as to affect the election or term of any Senator chosen before it becomes valid as part of the Constitution.

Commentary on this proposed amendment:

The purpose of this amendment is three-fold. 

First it offers a compromise between the method of election of Senators in the original Constitution and the way that it is done now under the Seventeenth Amendment.  This would have a better chance of passing than a simple repeal.  The State Legislatures would be able to choose the Senators, but there would many ways in which the electorate could still have a choice in a general election.  If a state has a bicameral legislature as most states do, it may frequently occur that two different candidates would be selected, and the electorate would be able to choose between the two.  And with the addition of the office of Vice Senator, being elected in the same manner, there is another chance for this to occur if there is to be a vacancy to be filled.  And finally, even if the legislature chooses only one candidate, there is at least one way in which the legislature may allow the electorate to reject their choice.  Note that Section 5 states “…if no candidate for the office shall have qualified, then the Vice Senator shall become Senator.”  The legislature could, for example, enact a “turkey ballot” law.  This would allow the voters to vote “none of the above” and if more such votes were cast than for any candidate, then all the candidates on the ballot would be disqualified.  In this case, the Vice Senator would become Senator. 

Secondly, it gives the States more flexibility in some respects than they had both before the seventeenth amendment and now. 

Thirdly, if the office of President is important enough to have a back-up, then shouldn’t also the office of Senator?  Senators serve 6 year terms whereas the President serves only four years.  And the Vice Senator would be backing up two offices, not just one.  The original Constitution states in Article V that “no State, without its Consent, shall be deprived of its equal Suffrage in the Senate”.  This amendment would help to fulfill the purpose of this statement by ensuring that any vacancies in the office are immediately filled.  Thus, every state is likely to have full participation in every vote in the Senate (except for the apathy of a Senator).  The creation of this office would also take most of the appointment power away from the Governor regarding Senators (and would allow the State Legislatures to take it all away if they wished).

Thursday, November 11, 2010

The Right Way to Amend the Constitution, part 20

This is part twenty of an ongoing series of articles containing my proposals for amendments to the Constitution.  For someone who claims so fervently to be a “Constitutionalist”, how is it that I can be so eager to change the Constitution?  Well, there are several reasons.  For one thing, I believe that after the Bill of Rights, much damage was done by some of the amendments that were added and the legitimacy of some of their ratifications are questionable.  Secondly, the Constitution has been violated so much that the necessity of further amendments is needed to resolve the resulting problems.  But this should be done extremely cautiously.  My amendments are extremely unlikely to ever be introduced, much less ratified, but hey, I can dream, can’t I?

After a long hiatus in this series, I have most recently come up with this:

Section 1.  An amendment to this Constitution may only be presented by Congress to the States for their consideration if two-thirds of the whole number of the members in their respective houses shall concur with the amendment.

Section 2.  Congress shall make no law penalizing or rewarding a State for ratifying, rejecting, or failing to ratify an amendment to this Constitution.  If Congress passes a law in violation of this section and if the affected amendment has not yet adopted into this Constitution, the presentment of the amendment shall be null and void.  Congress may withdraw an amendment which it has proposed at any time before it becomes a valid part of this Constitution.

Section 3.  Whenever an amendment is pending before the States and is not yet adopted into the Constitution, any State may change its position on ratification.

Section 4.  Ratification by a State of a pending amendment shall not be valid unless the State approves of the amendment exactly as proposed by Congress including all punctuation, capitalization, wording and spelling.

Section 5.  Any amendment purportedly adopted into this Constitution which would not have been valid if this amendment had been adopted prior to any purported action taken to adopt the purported amendment by either the Congress or the States, shall henceforth be inoperative until the conditions for adoption of amendments of the previous sections of this amendment and of Article V of this Constitution have been met.

Section 6.  This article of amendment shall be inoperative if not ratified under the conditions for adoption of amendments of the previous sections of this amendment and of Article V and shall not take effect until seven years following its ratification.

Commentary on this proposed amendment:

One purpose of this amendment would be to repeal the 14th, 16th, and possibly the 17th amendments.  The 15th amendment would also be lost through this amendment, but this amendment could probably easily be passed again and perhaps in an even better form (one which would, for example, not permit states from disqualifying people from running for office based on race and prohibit literacy tests).  I don’t know if there would be any other amendments removed from the Constitution, but the Corwin Amendment (a pro-slavery amendment) would be no longer be pending before the states because its passage in Congress did not meet the qualifications of Section 1.  Another purpose of the amendment would be to prevent any future amendments from being enacted which do not truly reflect the will of the people.  It corrects wrong interpretations of the Constitution concerning the amendment process like the two-thirds requirement being only of those present, the ability of the Congress to force the states to ratify an amendment, and the validity of inexact ratifications.  These misinterpretations have lead to the (alleged) adoption of these bad amendments without the proper super-majorities and great care which the Framers of the original Constitution intended.  This amendment would not be such a broad brush as an amendment which I had formulated earlier.

Thursday, March 11, 2010

The Right Way to Amend the Constitution, part 19

This is part nineteen of an ongoing series of articles containing my proposals for amendments to the Constitution. For someone who claims so fervently to be a “Constitutionalist”, how is it that I can be so eager to change the Constitution? Well, there are several reasons. For one thing, I believe that after the Bill of Rights, much damage was done by some of the amendments that were added and the legitimacy of some of their ratifications are questionable. Secondly, the Constitution has been violated so much that the necessity of further amendments is needed to resolve the resulting problems. But this should be done extremely cautiously. My amendments are extremely unlikely to ever be introduced, much less ratified, but hey, I can dream, can’t I?

In this post I am writing about a modification I have made to a previous proposed amendment and a withdrawal of another.

Section 6: Representatives and direct taxes shall be apportioned among the several states according to the number of born persons in each state excluding Indians not taxed.

I added the above new section to my pro-life constitutional amendment proposal. The original wording contained language requiring that all laws containing the word “person” would be interpreted as inclusive of the unborn. But it is not reasonable that unborn babies should be included in census enumerations. Historically, they were not included and it wouldn't be right to include some while others are not included because the mother is not yet aware of the pregnancy. Forcing women to take a pregnancy test would be excessively intrusive and not necessarily reliable.

I am also being kind of sneaky with this because this would also nullify the 16th amendment (if had ever been properly ratified in the first place). No more direct, unapportioned taxes.

Secondly, I am withdrawing my proposal to amend the constitution to remove Barack Obama from office as this would be a Bill of Attainder. I still agree that he should be removed, but the method I had proposed is unacceptable. Article I section 9 forbids Bills of Attainder which I can now see should even include constitutional amendments. This must be done through the courts. But future crises such as this could be avoided with a clarifying amendment.

Thursday, November 19, 2009

The Right Way to Amend the Constitution, part 18


This is part eighteen of an ongoing series of articles containing my proposals for amendments to the Constitution. For someone who claims so fervently to be a “Constitutionalist”, how is it that I can be so eager to change the Constitution? Well, there are several reasons. For one thing, I believe that after the Bill of Rights, much damage was done by some of the amendments that were added and the legitimacy of some of their ratifications are questionable. Secondly, the Constitution has been violated so much that the necessity of further amendments is needed to resolve the resulting problems. But this should be done extremely cautiously. My amendments are extremely unlikely to ever be introduced, much less ratified, but hey, I can dream, can’t I?
Here is my eighteenth proposed amendment (subject to revision):
The President may not enter into a treaty or other international agreement that would provide for the United States to adopt as legal tender in the United States a currency issued by an entity other than the United States.
Commentary on this proposed amendment:
This amendment was actually introduced by Congresswoman Michelle Bachmann. It is cosponsored by Ron Paul, but I am wondering if it is really necessary. Article I section 8 says, “The Congress shall have Power…To coin Money, regulate the Value thereof, and of foreign Coin…” But the word “tender” is not used in association with any power of the federal government. If we assume that the power to make something tender is included in the definition of “regulate the value thereof” then I think the amendment would be meaningful. But the word “regulate” means to make regular or uniform, not to determine. It seems incomprehensible that the Founding Fathers would have meant for Congress to have the right to make a foreign coin legal tender, much less the President. "No State shall ... coin Money,...make any Thing but gold and silver Coin a Tender in Payment of Debts..." If the federal gov't has all power over the issue, then giving the states the power to make gold and silver Coin a Tender means nothing.

Click here to read the next article in the series.

Thursday, October 29, 2009

The Right Way to Amend the Constitution, part 16

This is part sixteen of an ongoing series of articles containing proposals for amendments to the Constitution. For someone who claims so fervently to be a “Constitutionalist”, how is it that I can be so eager to change the Constitution? Well, there are several reasons. For one thing, I believe that after the Bill of Rights, much damage was done by some of the amendments that were added and the legitimacy of some of their ratifications are questionable. Secondly, the Constitution has been violated so much that the necessity of further amendments is needed to resolve the resulting problems. But this should be done extremely cautiously. These amendments are extremely unlikely to ever be introduced, much less ratified, but hey, I can dream, can’t I?

The title for this week’s proposed article of amendment (subject to revision) is The “Downsize D.C.” Amendment, the text of which follows:

Section 1: The citizens of the District shall be included among the population of a State in the next Census following the ratification of this article.

Section 2: The twenty-third amendment to this Constitution is hereby repealed.

Section 3: The mayor, city council, and all other legislative and executive offices of power within the city of the constituting the seat of Government of the United States shall be dissolved.

Section 4: The District shall be annexed into the State referred to in section 1, except for needful buildings lawfully under the control of the United States.

Section 5: No Person shall take up permanent residence within the District after the annexation.

Section 6: If this article of amendment is ratified by the State of Maryland, then the State referred to in section 1 shall be Maryland. If this article of amendment is not ratified by the state of Maryland, but is ratified by the State of Virginia, then the State referred to in section 1 shall be Virginia. If this article of amendment is not ratified by either Maryland or Virginia, then this entire article shall be inoperable.

Section 7: Sections 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6 shall take effect upon completion of the next Census following the ratification of this article.

Section 8: Congress shall have power to enforce this article by appropriate legislation.

Commentary on this proposed amendment:

It isn’t right that some citizens of the United States should not be represented in Congress, but Washington D.C. should not have the rights of a state (including having Presidential Electors). One reason for this is because states have the right to secede. If the District seceded, then there would no longer be a Seat of Government. Another reason is that the population of D.C. is now smaller than that of the least populous state (Alaska). They also couldn’t be founded as other states were without a Constitutional amendment because their limited sovereignty (see below) is written into the Constitution.

George Washington made a deal with Alexander Hamilton to expand the size of D.C. so that Washington’s property would be contained in it. In exchange, Hamilton got a Central Bank. This was a bad deal on both ends for Americans.

Most of the Founders never intended that ordinary citizens would take up permanent residence in the District. If they do, they have no constitutional right to self-government (except to vote for 3 Presidential Electors, as stated in the 23rd amendment), but should be governed solely by Congress. Congress cannot properly abdicate their authority to a city government. All of the complaining about the sovereignty of D.C. ignores the Constitution. Article I, section 8, clause 16 makes it clear:

The Congress shall have Power… To exercise exclusive Legislation in all Cases whatsoever, over such District… the Seat of the Government of the United States…

In fact, the only reason why we even need a Constitutional amendment for this is because the 23rd amendment needs to be repealed. The rest of it could just be passed through by Congress and either the state of Maryland or Virginia.

Let’s get the residents of D.C. out of the mess that they’re in and get them into an existing state so that they can have the same rights as all other Americans without ignoring the Constitution or further damaging the Republic. We need to move quickly on this in order to get it done before the 2010 Census.

Click here to read the next article in this series.

Thursday, October 22, 2009

The Right Way to Amend the Constitution, part 15


This is part fifteen of an ongoing series of articles containing my proposals for amendments to the Constitution. For someone who claims so fervently to be a “Constitutionalist”, how is it that I can be so eager to change the Constitution? Well, there are several reasons. For one thing, I believe that after the Bill of Rights, much damage was done by some of the amendments that were added and the legitimacy of some of their ratifications are questionable. Secondly, the Constitution has been violated so much that the necessity of further amendments is needed to resolve the resulting problems. But this should be done extremely cautiously. My amendments are extremely unlikely to ever be introduced, much less ratified, but hey, I can dream, can’t I?

Here is my fifteenth proposed amendment (subject to revision):

If any citizen of the United States shall accept, claim, receive, or retain any title of nobility or honour, or shall without the consent of Congress, accept and retain any present, pension, office, or emolument of any kind whatever, from any Emperor, King, Prince, or foreign Power, such person shall cease to be a citizen of the United States, and shall be incapable of holding any office of trust or profit under them, or either of them.

Commentary on this proposed amendment:

While many people believe that the 14th, 16th, and 17th amendments were never properly ratified, the above is an amendment that was many believe was properly ratified, but is now not recognized as being part of the Constitution. For documented evidence of this, go to http://www.barefootsworld.net/real13th.html.

The Constitution had already said, in Article I section 9:

No Title of Nobility shall be granted by the United States: And no Person holding any Office of Profit or Trust under them, shall, without the Consent of the Congress, accept of any present, Emolument, Office, or Title, of any kind whatever, from any King, Prince, or foreign State.

With Barack Obama having joined the ranks of warmongers Woodrow Wilson and Yassir Arafat in receiving the Nobel Peace Prize, this is yet another thing which disqualifies him from holding the office of Presidency. (I don’t care if there were three other Presidents who accepted the NPP—they should have been impeached also.) Furthermore, if it is really true that the real 13th amendment is really the one ratified in 1812, Obama’s alleged citizenship of the United States has been forfeited if he ever even had it.

Removing Obama from the office of the Presidency should be just the beginning. Various titles are given to individuals which impart certain powers such as Doctor, Attorney, etc. These titles give their bearers the authority to practice certain disciplines from which others are barred. Institutions governed by those who were not elected by the people and whose powers are not derived from the Constitution have been unconstitutionally given the authority to impart these privileges. These titles are clear violations of the Constitution which also says:

No State shall… grant any Title of Nobility.

This was clearly meant to protect the American people from a government that could gain control of certain fields. To forbid anyone from practicing in a field unless you do it the way the government says disrupts the freedom of people to decide for themselves who is and who isn’t qualified to perform a certain task.

Click here to read the article in this series.

Wednesday, September 02, 2009

The Right Way to Amend the Constitution, part 11

This is part eleven of an ongoing series of articles containing proposals for amendments to the Constitution. For someone who claims so fervently to be a “Constitutionalist”, how is it that I can be so eager to change the Constitution? Well, there are several reasons. For one thing, I believe that after the Bill of Rights, much damage was done by some of the amendments that were added and the legitimacy of some of their ratifications are questionable. Secondly, the Constitution has been violated so much that the necessity of further amendments is needed to resolve the resulting problems. But this should be done extremely cautiously. These amendments are extremely unlikely to ever be introduced, much less ratified, but hey, I can dream, can’t I?

Here is another proposed amendment (subject to revision):

After the first enumeration, required by the first article of the constitution, there shall be one representative for every thirty thousand, until the number shall amount to one hundred. After which the proportion shall be so regulated by Congress, that there shall be not less than one hundred representatives, nor less than one representative for every forty thousand per-sons, until the number of Representatives shall amount to two hundred, after which the proportion shall be so regulated by Congress, that there shall not be less than two hundred representatives, nor less than one representative for every fifty thousand persons.

There were originally 12 amendments in the proposed Bill of Rights. This amendment was one of the two that didn’t get enough votes to be ratified with the others. The other one, having to do with limits on congressional pay raises, was finally ratified in 1992 and became the 27th amendment.

I think that this amendment is a good idea because it, along with repealing the 17th amendment, would bring the Congress “closer to the people”. It’s harder to hold them accountable if they represent such a large population.

A disadvantage of this amendment would be that the states would no longer have as much “say” in the Presidential elections. (The Presidential elections would be much closer to a “popular vote”.) But if we followed the Constitution, we would still much further away from a democracy than the true constitutional republic that we are supposed to be.

Click here to read more about this issue. Click here to read the next article in this series.

Thursday, August 27, 2009

The Right Way to Amend the Constitution, part 10

This article was modified on 3/6/10.


This is part ten of an ongoing series of articles containing proposals for amendments to the Constitution. For someone who claims so fervently to be a “Constitutionalist”, how is it that I can be so eager to change the Constitution? Well, there are several reasons. For one thing, I believe that after the Bill of Rights, much damage was done by some of the amendments that were added and the legitimacy of some of their ratifications are questionable. Secondly, the Constitution has been violated so much that the necessity of further amendments is needed to resolve the resulting problems. But this should be done extremely cautiously. These amendments are extremely unlikely to ever be introduced, much less ratified, but hey, I can dream, can’t I?

Here is this week’s proposed amendment (subject to revision):

Section 1: A “human life” or “human being” shall be deemed to include each and every member of the species homo sapiens at all stages of life, beginning with the earliest stage of development, created by the process of fertilization, cloning, or its functional equivalent and without regard to race, sex, age, health, defect, or condition of dependency.

Section 2: For purposes of this article, the term “fertilization” means the process of a human spermatozoan penetrating the cell membrane of a human oocyte to create a human zygote, a one-celled human embryo, which is a new unique human being.

Section 3: For purposes of this article, the term “cloning” means the process called somatic cell nuclear transfer, which combines an enucleated egg and the nucleus of a somatic cell to make a human embryo.

Section 4: All uses of the term “person” in any law of the United States, including this Constitution, shall be construed as inclusive of all human life as defined in sections 1, 2, and 3 of this article.

Section 5: All human beings are created equal and are endowed by their Creator with the unalienable Right to Life. Neither the United States nor any State shall deny any person within its jurisdiction this Right without due process.

Section 6: Representatives and direct taxes shall be apportioned among the several states according to the number of born persons in each state excluding Indians not taxed.

Commentary on this proposed amendment:

The first three sections are based on Paul Broun’s Sanctity of Human Life Act. Section 5 comes from the Declaration of Independence with the phrase “All men” replaced with “All human beings” and only the Right to Life is included.

I never thought that it would be so difficult to write an effective Human Life Amendment. What I am trying to accomplish is to make all laws against murder to apply equally to all people (including the unborn), without denying someone’s right to self-defense, while still allowing the States to set their own punishments for murder and to be chiefly responsible for enforcing these laws. “Without due process” allows the death penalty, self defense laws, and legal wars to remain.

I added section 6 because it is not reasonable that unborn babies should be included in census enumerations. Historically, they were not included and it wouldn't be right to include some while others are not included because the mother is not yet aware of the pregnancy. Forcing women to take a pregnancy test would be excessively intrusive.

Click here to read the next article in the series.

Thursday, August 20, 2009

The Right Way to Amend the Constitution, part 9


This is part nine of an ongoing series of articles containing proposals for amendments to the Constitution. For someone who claims so fervently to be a “Constitutionalist”, how is it that I can be so eager to change the Constitution? Well, there are several reasons. For one thing, I believe that after the Bill of Rights, much damage was done by some of the amendments that were added and the legitimacy of some of their ratifications are questionable. Secondly, the Constitution has been violated so much that the necessity of further amendments is needed to resolve the resulting problems. But this should be done extremely cautiously. These amendments are extremely unlikely to ever be introduced, much less ratified, but hey, I can dream, can’t I?

Here is this week’s proposed amendment (subject to revision):

Section 1: The United States Post Office, all of its subsidiaries, and any mail delivery services under the control of the United States shall, within a period of three years from the date of the ratification of this amendment, be liquidated and the properties and facilities affected shall be sold. The proceeds from these sales shall be used to pay down the National Debt.

Section 2: All restrictions in the laws of the United States on the delivery of mail by private mail delivery services are hereby repealed.

Section 3: The Power to establish a Post office and Post roads shall no longer be vested in Congress.

This amendment is needed because the Post Office, like all other government run businesses is full of waste. Also, this is a subject not covered in the Liberty Amendment, because the Constitution does give the Congress the right to establish a Post Office. With the advent of email and the internet, this service is no longer as crucial as it once was. And if it was adopted, the employees of the Post Office would then be working for private corporations which would be less likely to selectively harass them for their political beliefs (the Hatch Act restricts political activities of Federal employees).

According to the Von Mises Institute, even Barack Obama says, “It's the post office that's always having problems …” in an inept attempt to downplay the effect of private businesses being driven out of business by government run businesses. What way to prove the point that government businesses are an OK thing! Read more of this story at:

http://mises.org/story/3646

Click here to read the next article in the series.

Thursday, August 13, 2009

The Right Way to Amend the Constitution, part 8

This is part eight of an ongoing series of articles containing proposals for amendments to the Constitution. For someone who claims so fervently to be a “Constitutionalist”, how is it that I can be so eager to change the Constitution? Well, there are several reasons. For one thing, I believe that after the Bill of Rights, much damage was done by some of the amendments that were added and the legitimacy of some of their ratifications are questionable. Secondly, the Constitution has been violated so much that the necessity of further amendments is needed to resolve the resulting problems. But this should be done extremely cautiously. These amendments are extremely unlikely to ever be introduced, much less ratified, but hey, I can dream, can’t I?

The title for this week’s proposed article of amendment (subject to revision) is The Legal Racial Distinctions Abolishment Amendment, the text of which follows:

Section 1: All uses of the term “person” in any law of any State or of the United States, including this Constitution, shall be construed as inclusive of all races of human beings.

Section 2: No law of any State or of the United States, except this article of amendment, shall make reference to a distinction between races or skin colors.

Section 3: All references to a distinction between races contained in any law of any State or of the United States, including this Constitution, shall become inoperable when this amendment is ratified.

Section 4: This amendment shall not be construed to affect the sovereignty of Indian tribes.

Commentary on this proposed amendment:

My motivation for this amendment is the belief that laws which require people to be classified by race are the major cause of racism. The fact or perception that one race is more protected under the law than another is the reason for this. This would tend to go away with this amendment. Private entities could still have affirmative action programs if they chose to do so, but I think that this would go away with time. The courts might have to make a ruling on whether or not policies of public institutions are considered “law” for purposes of this amendment. That would be interesting indeed.

Click here to read the next article in this series.

Thursday, August 06, 2009

The Right Way to Amend the Constitution, part 7

This is part seven of an ongoing series of articles containing proposals for amendments to the Constitution. For someone who claims so fervently to be a “Constitutionalist”, how is it that I can be so eager to change the Constitution? Well, there are several reasons. For one thing, I believe that after the Bill of Rights, much damage was done by some of the amendments that were added and the legitimacy of some of their ratifications are questionable. Secondly, the Constitution has been violated so much that the necessity of further amendments is needed to resolve the resulting problems. But this should be done extremely cautiously. These amendments are extremely unlikely to ever be introduced, much less ratified, but hey, I can dream, can’t I?

The title for this week’s proposed article of amendment (subject to revision) is The Interstate Commerce Clause Abolishment Amendment, the text of which follows:

The United States shall not regulate commerce among the several States.

Commentary on this proposed amendment:

Article I section 8 states:

The Congress shall have Power to … regulate Commerce with foreign Nations, and among the several States, and with the Indian Tribes.

Due to the routine abuse of this clause and the fact that the United States is much larger than it was when the Founders formulated the Constitution, I think the power of the Congress should be revoked in this matter.

This clause has been used to say that a man can’t feed his own cattle with his own wheat because if he doesn’t make it available to people in other states, then it affects interstate commerce. Of course, this is obviously judicial activism, but in other cases it’s iffy. I believe that the original definition of “regulate” was “to make regular”, not “to make (any) rules concerning”. Article I section 9 says:

No Tax or Duty shall be laid on Articles exported from any State. No Preference shall be given by any Regulation of Commerce or Revenue to the Ports of one State over those of another; nor shall Vessels bound to, or from, one State, be obliged to enter, clear, or pay Duties in another.

I believe that this is the sort of thing (fair trade) that the Founders were talking about (the clause in section 8 could be extended to similar situations), not banning export of oranges from Florida if they aren’t orange enough or if they have too much pesticide on them.

Click here for the next article in this series.

Thursday, July 30, 2009

The Right Way to Amend the Constitution, part 6


This is part six of an ongoing series of articles containing proposals for amendments to the Constitution. For someone who claims so fervently to be a “Constitutionalist”, how is it that I can be so eager to change the Constitution? Well, there are several reasons. For one thing, I believe that after the Bill of Rights, much damage was done by some of the amendments that were added and the legitimacy of some of their ratifications are questionable. Secondly, the Constitution has been violated so much that the necessity of further amendments is needed to resolve the resulting problems. But this should be done extremely cautiously. These amendments are extremely unlikely to ever be introduced, much less ratified, but hey, I can dream, can’t I?

In lieu of writing a new proposal for a Constitutional amendment, I will further comment on the one I posted last week, The Audacity of Legitimacy Amendment. Click here to read it in its entirety.

I have a few comments on Section 4, which says, “The House of Representatives shall, within 48 hours of the ratification of this article, select a President in the manner described in Article II section 1 Clause 3 and elsewhere in this Constitution as if no Person had received a majority of votes in the last Electoral College in Dispute. The President so selected shall be elected to complete the remainder of the term held by the de facto President.”

The House could not just pick anybody to fill out the remainder of Barack Obama’s term. In fact, if this amendment were to be ratified in during Mr. Obama’s alleged first term, then I believe John McCain (unfortunately) would become the President. This is because he is the only one who received any legitimate electoral votes for President. In both Article II section 1 Clause 3 and the 12th Amendment, the House is limited to the “persons having the highest numbers [of electoral votes] not exceeding [five in Article II and three in the 12th Amendment] on the list of those voted for as President”. I would assume that “voted” refers to the Electoral College vote and that if someone did not get any Electoral College votes, then they are not “on the list”. I could always add additional conditions, but I would rather have as little interference with what the Constitution already says as possible.

If this Amendment were to pass while Mr. Obama illegally holds the office of the Presidency and after the next the Presidential election day, but before the Electoral College vote, and if he was reelected (in the Electoral College vote), then 20th Amendment would apply. In this case, Obama’s running mate would act as President beginning January 20th, 2013 and “until a President shall have qualified”. If the amendment passes in Obama’s second (usurped) term, then the conditions in the previous paragraph would prevail, with those receiving electoral votes in 2012 being voted on by the House. The 20th Amendment would also be applied in the case that John McCain died or if he became ineligible. In that case, Congress “may by law provide…declaring who shall then act as President, or the manner in which one who is to act shall be selected…”

The first portion of Section 5 is intended to cover the unlikely case in which the only eligible Presidential candidate is also the Vice President. That would mean, for example, Joe Biden would be removed from office and the vacancy would be filled by John McCain (at Obama’s choice). Since the election of Joe Biden is relatively legitimate, he should be left in office.

But that brings up an interesting point. Even though Joe Biden’s eligibility to become Vice President is not in question, the actual manner in which he was elected is somewhat questionable. In some states, a Vice Presidential candidate is not eligible to receive electors if the other member of ticket is not eligible. This makes some, but not all of Joe Biden’s electoral votes illegitimate. I’m not going to take the time to find out if he would still have had enough votes to beat Sarah Palin. (The Electoral College ballots for President and Vice President are distinct according to the 12th Amendment. If any of Biden’s votes are illegitimate, these votes would all presumably go to Palin.) But the current wording of my amendment overrides all of this, making Joe Biden’s election official (if he is in fact, the de facto Vice President at the time that the amendment is ratified or similarly if another running mate or Vice President was subsequently chosen by Mr. Obama).

Finally, I want to explore a little bit about what would happen if Mr. Obama were declared ineligible and my amendment did not pass. Ordinarily, if a law is passed by Congress and if the President does not sign it in so many days, then it becomes law just as if he did. But what if there is no President? Is Joe Biden our real President (by the 20th Amendment)? Even if this is so, there have been other actions taken by Mr. Obama (such as executive orders) which are illegal since he is not our President. These would have to be dealt with in some way.

Stay “tuned” for another proposed constitutional amendment next week.

Thursday, June 25, 2009

The Right Way to Amend the Constitution, part 1


This is part one of an ongoing series of articles containing proposals for amendments to the Constitution. For someone who claims so fervently to be a “Constitutionalist”, how is it that I can be so eager to change the Constitution? Well, there are several reasons. For one thing, I believe that after the Bill of Rights, much damage was done by some of the amendments that were added and the legitimacy of some of their ratifications are questionable. Secondly, the Constitution has been violated so much that the necessity of further amendments is needed to resolve the resulting problems. But this should be done extremely cautiously. These amendments are extremely unlikely to ever be introduced, much less ratified, but hey, I can dream, can’t I?

Here is the proposed amendment:

The following words shall be added at the end of the sentence which constitutes the Preamble of this Constitution:

…recognizing Almighty God as the source of all authority and power in civil government, and acknowledging the Lord Jesus Christ as the Governor among nations, His revealed will as the supreme law of the land, in order to constitute a Christian government.

Commentary on this proposed amendment:
...
Some Christians tried to have this added at about the time of the civil war. The Preamble currently reads:
...
We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.

Click here to see next week's proposed amendment.

Thursday, January 31, 2008

Ron Paul on Abortion Amendment

GregJaye asked this question in response to my comment on a recent post:

My question about Congressman Paul is: why is he not in favor of federal amendments on either the protection of human life or [sic] the protection of marriage? It is my understanding that he and Thompson preferred that the states deal with these issues. I don't agree. We must protect these traditional values from the runaway judiciary.

First I will answer the question about abortion.

I have never heard anyone say that Ron Paul would vote against a Constitutional Amendment to protect the unborn. On his website he says this:

The alternative is an outright federal ban on abortion, done properly via a constitutional amendment that does no violence to our way of government.

http://www.ronpaul2008.com/articles/81/pro-life-action-must-originate-from-principle/

This suggests the he would vote for a Constitutional amendment if it was properly worded. But it also implies that he thinks that this is not the best way. He prefers his Sanctity of Life Act. Here is why:

It would be easier to accomplish than a Constitutional amendment. We would only have to have a simple majority in the House and Senate and the President’s signature. A Constitutional amendment would additionally require approval of two-thirds of the state legislatures.

The Supreme Court does not really have the power that people think that it has. But Congress refuses to exert its authority over it as the Founding Fathers intended. This is the root of the problem of judicial activism. Judges become corrupt because they are unchecked as they are supposed to be.

The Constitution clearly says, “In all the other cases before-mentioned, the supreme court shall have appellate jurisdiction, both as to law and fact, with such exceptions, and under such regulations as the Congress shall make.” (Article III, section 2). If you read the whole section you can see that this applies to everything except things like interstate crimes, ambassadors, and some other public officials.

RP wants the Congress to use this provision of the Constitution to give us back our power that we have over the Supreme Court so that we don’t have to keep going through the arduous process of amending the constitution every time an activist Supreme Court takes away our God-given rights. It is also important to dispel the myth of Supreme Court power in the minds of the populace.

Duncan Hunter made this statement:

I would amend the U.S. Constitution and provide blanket protection to all unborn children from the moment of conception by prohibiting any state or federal law that denies the personhood of the unborn. Likewise, I have also introduced the Right to Life Act, which would legally define “personhood” as the moment of conception and, therefore, guarantee all constitutional rights and protections, including life, to the unborn without utilizing a constitutional amendment.

I don’t see that anything Ron Paul has said would be inconsistent with this. Laws against murder have always been state laws. RP just wants to keep things as they had always been before all this judicial activism. Just because someone says they believe in a constitutional amendment does not mean they have taken the most conservative position on the issue. One could conceive of different ways that a Constitutional Amendment could be worded. It could only allow the states to pass laws against abortion. It could ban all abortion outright. Mitt Romney supports such an amendment that would contain exceptions in cases of rape and incest. Mike Huckabee says the same thing as RP about leaving this issue up to the states. Maybe RPs strong beliefs in states' rights could inhibit his ability to act to protect the unborn in some situtuations (but he has voted for some federal legislation which criminalizes some abortions). And I must admit that RPs approach has one disadvantage--a Constitutional Amendment would be more permanent. You could rightly argue that Duncan Hunter is better on this issue, but that definately cannot be said of Mike Huckabee.

The reasoning behind not prefering a Constitutional Amendment against gay marriage are similar, but I’ll have much more to say about this next week.